A myth called justice essay

This review appears in the Winter—Fall issue of Modern Age.

A myth called justice essay

The Social Order Public safety The race industry and its elite enablers take it as self-evident that high black incarceration rates result from discrimination. After all, inblacks were About one in 33 black men was in prison incompared with one in white men and one in 79 Hispanic men. Eleven percent of all black males between the ages of 20 and 34 are in prison A myth called justice essay jail.

The dramatic rise in the prison and jail population over the last three decades—to 2. The favorite culprits for high black prison rates include a biased legal system, draconian drug enforcement, and even prison itself. None of these explanations stands up to scrutiny. The black incarceration rate is overwhelmingly a function of black crime.

Insisting otherwise only worsens black alienation and further defers a real solution to the black crime problem. Racial activists usually remain assiduously silent about that problem. But inthe black homicide rate was over seven times higher than that of whites and Hispanics combined, according to the federal Bureau of Justice Statistics.

From toblacks committed over 52 percent of all murders in America. The advocates acknowledge such crime data only indirectly: In fact, the race of criminals reported by crime victims matches arrest data.

As long ago asa study of robbery and aggravated assault in eight cities found parity between the race of assailants in victim identifications and in arrests—a finding replicated many times since, across a range of crimes.

No one has ever come up with a plausible argument as to why crime victims would be biased in their reports. Moving up the enforcement chain, the campaign against the criminal-justice system next claims that prosecutors overcharge and judges oversentence blacks.

As Charlotte Allen has brilliantly chronicled in The Weekly Standard, a local civil rights activist crafted a narrative linking the attack to an unrelated incident months earlier, in which three white students hung two nooses from a schoolyard tree—a display that may or may not have been intended as a racial provocation.

This entrepreneur then embellished the tale with other alleged instances of redneck racism—above all, the initial attempted-murder charges.

A myth called justice essay

If blacks were disproportionately in prison, the refrain went, it was because they faced biased prosecutors—like the one in Jena—as well as biased juries and judges. Backing up this bias claim has been the holy grail of criminology for decades—and the prize remains as elusive as ever.

Incriminologists Robert Sampson and Janet Lauritsen reviewed the massive literature on charging and sentencing. A analysis of Georgia felony convictions, for example, found that blacks frequently received disproportionately lenient punishment.

Following conviction, blacks were more likely to receive prison sentences, however—an outcome that reflected the gravity of their offenses as well as their criminal records.

Another criminologist—easily as liberal as Sampson—reached the same conclusion in Tonry did go on to impute malign racial motives to drug enforcement, however. An entire industry in the law schools now dedicates itself to flushing out prosecutorial and judicial bias, using ever more complicated statistical artillery.

A few new studies show tiny, unexplained racial disparities in sentencing, while other analyses continue to find none. Any differences that do show up are trivially small compared with the exponentially greater rates of criminal offending among blacks.

No criminologist would claim, moreover, to have controlled for every legal factor that affects criminal-justice outcomes, says Patrick Langan, former senior statistician for the Bureau of Justice Statistics.

Some criminologists replace statistics with High Theory in their search for racism. The criminal-justice system does treat individual suspects and criminals equally, they concede.

But the problem is how society defines crime and criminals. Crime is a social construction designed to marginalize minorities, these theorists argue. Unfair drug policies are an equally popular explanation for black incarceration rates.

Legions of pundits, activists, and academics charge that the war on drugs is a war on minorities—a de facto war at best, an intentional one at worst.

Playing a starring role in this conceit are federal crack penalties, the source of the greatest amount of misinformation in the race and incarceration debate. Under the federal Anti-Drug Abuse Act, getting caught with five grams of crack carries a mandatory minimum five-year sentence in federal court; to trigger the same five-year minimum, powder-cocaine traffickers would have to get caught with grams.

A myth called justice essay

On average, federal crack sentences are three to six times longer than powder sentences for equivalent amounts.Plato's Works Essay examples Words | 8 Pages.

Plato's Works In his works, Plato writes about truth, justice, and reality in full detail. The border between juvenile justice and criminal justice did not endure the juvenile court’s first century.

By the s, there was general disappointment with both the means and the ends of normal juvenile justice. Whether it be through criminal acts being heightened to a crime myth or exaggerating ordinary events in life.

Crime myths fill in the gaps to provide answers to questions for the public. Pursuing a Degree in Criminal Justice Essay - Today our world is filled with crime. The system in place to keeping everything fair and safe is called. The Myth of a Fair Criminal Justice System Introduction The word fair is defined by Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary () as “marked by.

Eight common myths that make the US justice system seem fairer than it is. By Alex Kozinski August 28, Other types of forensic evidence have also been called into question by recent scholarship. Platonic Justice Essay.

Spring 2008

society in which justice symbolizes the virtuous, since Plato believed justice is there to be the prescription for the evils. and how can this destructive process be called justice? In The Oresteia, the cycle is a familiar one, but is also interweaved with gender issues and a sense of justice that changes within the.

The Myth of Criminal-Justice Racism | City Journal